+11

Mattke

TheGeorgian

mutantsushi

dino00

George1

Werewolf

Regular

GarryB

As Sa'iqa

TR1

DostoevskyRasputin

15 posters

Go to page :

1, 2

If USSR won Afghan war?

KiloGolf

KiloGolf: Posts : 2481
Points : 2461
Join date : 2015-09-01
Location : Macedonia, Hellas

Post n°26

Re: If USSR won Afghan war?

KiloGolf Wed Jan 04, 2017 11:29 am

nastle77 wrote:I think this is a good thread to discuss battle of jalalabad in 1989 when the mujahideen bandits were repelled by najeebullah forces despite extensive help from pakistan

Any articles or sources that describe this battle in detail ?

Have a look at this:

1989 was a great year for the Afghanistan government. The Muj basically failed in making any progress, in fact they became irrelevant. Aso guess who was in-charge of the failed Jalalabad battle of 1989:

If USSR won Afghan war? - Page 2 Osama-history-1-popup

Essam Draz/Balkis Press/SIPA Bin Laden directing guerrillas near Jalalabad in 1989, when he was receiving assistance from the United States during Afghanistan's war against the Soviet Union. wrote:

Finty likes this post

nastle77

nastle77: Posts : 229
Points : 307
Join date : 2015-07-25

Post n°27

Re: If USSR won Afghan war?

nastle77 Wed Jan 04, 2017 10:46 pm

These brutal Afghan savages
Hope the soviets killed 20 for every young conscript they lost

George1

George1: Posts : 18519
Points : 19024
Join date : 2011-12-22
Location : Greece

Post n°28

Re: If USSR won Afghan war?

George1 Sun Feb 17, 2019 8:24 pm

Mokrushin: VTsIOM: 42% of Russians polled think the USSR didn't have to invade Afghanistan, 72% don't want to know more about Afghanistan.

https://twower.livejournal.com/2342396.html

nastle77

nastle77: Posts : 229
Points : 307
Join date : 2015-07-25

Post n°29

Re: If USSR won Afghan war?

nastle77 Fri May 29, 2020 9:48 pm

DostoevskyRasputin wrote:Privyet everyone!

I am an American citizen. I don't admire everything the USSR/ Russia has done, but I feel that their Afghan war, if not just, was not worth opposing. I feel president Reagen made an error in aiding the mujahadeen.

What if USSr had won? Would Afghanistan today be a better place, with more rights for women, and less anarchy and chaos?

Any ideas?

USSR did win the Afghan war , it militarily trounced the mujahedeen

They lost the peace as muj groups had wealthy powerful backers overseas

GarryB

GarryB: Posts : 40538
Points : 41038
Join date : 2010-03-30
Location : New Zealand

Post n°30

Re: If USSR won Afghan war?

GarryB Sat May 30, 2020 6:22 am

Very simply military power does not guarantee a win, but when the enemy is getting support from a Super Power and Saudi Arabias bottomless pockets and of course a border to hide over in the form of the border with Pakistan then there was no winning... all they could do is leave... which they did... and the enemy can call that a win but the Afghan people themselves were the biggest losers and missed out on some development and progress into the 20th century, but their help from Soviet enemies just cost them a real future. Billions of dollars have been spent on Afghanistan... most of the money spent by the Soviets was trying to rebuild and improve the place... the money spent by the west was to kill and murder and destroy, so despite all the money invested into the country it is still in a terrible state with little future prospects things will get better.

America spent a lot more money on Afghanistan and has been there twice as long and they are not winning hearts and minds at all... and that is without any major power supporting their enemy and arming them...

The Soviets were outplayed by the west, but the Americans are losing to the afghans on their own... even with their HATO allies...

magnumcromagnon

magnumcromagnon: Posts : 8138
Points : 8273
Join date : 2013-12-05
Location : Pindos ave., Pindosville, Pindosylvania, Pindostan

Post n°31

Re: If USSR won Afghan war?

magnumcromagnon Sat May 30, 2020 7:00 pm

GarryB wrote:Very simply military power does not guarantee a win, but when the enemy is getting support from a Super Power and Saudi Arabias bottomless pockets and of course a border to hide over in the form of the border with Pakistan then there was no winning... all they could do is leave... which they did... and the enemy can call that a win but the Afghan people themselves were the biggest losers and missed out on some development and progress into the 20th century, but their help from Soviet enemies just cost them a real future. Billions of dollars have been spent on Afghanistan... most of the money spent by the Soviets was trying to rebuild and improve the place... the money spent by the west was to kill and murder and destroy, so despite all the money invested into the country it is still in a terrible state with little future prospects things will get better.

America spent a lot more money on Afghanistan and has been there twice as long and they are not winning hearts and minds at all... and that is without any major power supporting their enemy and arming them...

The Soviets were outplayed by the west, but the Americans are losing to the afghans on their own... even with their HATO allies...

But their is a silver-lining, as some celestial-justice is being carried out: 1.) The US Afghan adventure was worse than the USSR's equivalent, 2.) The Pakistani's got their just desserts seeing it spilled in to Pakistan (causing over 600,000 deaths), 3.) The Saudi-Mights (Sodom Arabia) are getting reamed in their very own Afghan quagmire in Yemen! Embarassed