sepheronx wrote:Russian banks have not been doing well. They reported losses in funds when prior crisis was still gain in funds. Sberbank isnt Russian and is indeed working in their own interests rather than the nations. Evident is indeed Crimea since Crimea is Russian and if they operate there, shouldnt be of matter to them politically as they are supposed to be a Russian bank dealing in Russian activities. But, they dont. VTB banks is clearly helping Ukraine with increasing its investments there. If medvedev, Prime Minister is questioning the policies of the banks, then you know something is wrong.
The issue at hand is that Sberbank is main holder of Russias FOREX, so they can hold the government by the balls. And CBR has controlling stake in Sberbank which is technically a no no in international banking.
Russian government has to come down very hard on German Gref, which isnt Russian anyway, and owner of VTB. Helping the enemy to save a buck shouldnt be the case, and should be treason. But this isnt unheard of. In past, american companies used to assist Nazi Germany even if they were at war.
But did you read the claims of the report?
Is says in Absolute terms that Americans Federal Reserve controls Russia.. and this is
completely False . For me Russian central bank are like the Sukhoi Superjet 100 project.
that even thought the company is Russian ,the plane some parts are not done in Russia..
The engines are Russian done.. and the computer system too..if remember well. and the hull of the plane too and other things.. the avionics are french or forgot which company. the gears are american , the air conditioner.. and plane seats from another..
So is a collective project.. Where Russia is the major shareholder ....
Against the Russian Central bank is majority shares are controlled by Russian Government.
THis means that they could have if needed to have the last saying over anything. And this is
completely contradict the claims that Russian bank is controlled by the west or got by the balls.
Why the sukjoi 1000 is a good idea as a collective project? Because it allows Russia to enter
western markets ,and sell their planes there where the big money flows.. otherwise they will
be limited to only Russia and Asian markets.. And this is a HUGE advantage . Yes not all the plane sales will be in control of Russia and not all the profits will go to Russia but the plane
majority of it is Russian.. and Russia can shut down the project anytime they want.. see?
So just like the SUkhoi ,Russia benefit enormously by having a collective Bank with foreign capital invested on it.. because will allow Russia their own Bank to have bigger pockets while at the same time keeping the doors opened with the western banking system ,while at the same time controlling the majority of it.
Did you saw the part where i told of Russian banks bypassing American sanctions in europe?
Did that sounds to you like a bank "not controlled by Russia". Interest of the Russian Central
bank are the interest of its Shareholders..and Russia have majority of shareholders there.
So is not under american control.. but Russian control.. yes not an absolute control and already the benefits of it explained.. ie.. Open doors with western financial system and larger capital and bigger profits . Because means Russian banks can operate in Europe too and in America and in any part of the world and not just in Russia. So the Non-Russian Shareholders makes a lot of money.. but the Russian shareholders makes even more.. see?
The fact that Russian gold reserves are NOT stored in US banks like all Europeans.. do..
but in Russia.. should be very telling of who is in control of what.. MaxKeyser.. the expert
economist at RT ,who have pretty good knowledge of what happens with world economy, and who moves what, have told before that Russia central Bank is the only bank in world
that the Rothshild and Rockefellers the IMF cannot control. Do that sound like Russia is owned
by the west?
Reason why i think Russia Government does not use its powers and nationalize the bank completely .(which they could do any time easily ) it had to be because it could destroy the value of the shares of the bank and bring down the value of the Ruble if it is perceived as being a closed national bank and no longer international and open to investors. and no longer will be able to participate in wallstreet.. is not because they sold to americans.. but because they want to attract money to Russia...
One little secret about America is that their even though its Government that is controlled by wallstreet have ultimate word on anything.. is that every American Company Also have
their own Interest too and they are not united.. and not always in line with what each US governments administration wants. and this is why you see companies like Shell or Exxon at times bypassing US sanctions and working with Gazprom and Rossfnet. You have US senate trying to blockade pentagon shopping of Russian engines.. etc etc etc.. USA is not a united corporation.. but many Mega companies and each one with different interest.. not always in line
with US Government. So Russia can take advantage of that division ,and literary lure away American companies , Big ones and twist the arms of the white house.. This happened with the US space industry. and why Russia can continue selling rocket engines even though the Republican Senate and congress oppose it.
All said i see nothing wrong with the Russia central bank.. If Russia government needs something its needs to negotiate.. it will not be a dictatorship but neither Russia will be
powerless to force the bank to do what they want. this is the way i see it..
if Europe goes and increase sanctions on Russia and stop any trade.. then Russia will be justified to nationalize the bank withing minutes since no longer there will be any point to keep doors open if the west completely close them.
Did i mention that Russian Evil banks are bypassing American and European sanctions in Europe? Did i mention that Russia is not using dollars anymore in many of its transactions and
the the head of the central bank is defended by Putin its actions?
So unless people want to say Putin is in bed with American.. and is an idiot ,, i don't think Putin is a fool .. they have an strategy. And making money and defeating western sanctions and american banks financial hegemony IS part of that strategy;.
Head of the Russian Central Bank,Elvira Nabiullina ,elected by President Vladimir Putin.
Was accused of being a traitor by so called "economy experts" in Saker Forums interviews.. and accused her of completely ignoring Putin Demands for an alternative to the american control
Swift payment system... well guess what? they were wrong..
Here Vladimir Putin policies implemented as he asked by the Russian central bank.
http://rbth.com/business/2015/06/03/russia_unveils_new_national_payment_card_mir_46615.html
So is not a "western controlled bank". as people claim.. Is a Semi private ,semi national Bank.
Where Russia have majority of control.. but that they need to negotiate with its non Russian Shareholders.. too.. and even thought this is a limitation.. the benefits Russia gets in change
Far surpass the limitations. Otherwise Russia will need to nationlize the bank..and Russia will lose any access to International internet trade,no visa ,no mastercard ,with the west and major problem for the convenience of Russian people.. It will be a complete isolation from western business and Russia is not interested in that.. For me Russia policy under Putin is of leading
Russia with Brutal practical approach.. What can allow Russia obtain the major economic interest possible in the shortest time. Remember that Russia is still selling Gas to Ukraine after
all the killing of ethnic Russians.. but i don't see anyone claiming Gazprom is not under control of Russian government.. See? The logic is to maintain open relations with Ukraine ,even if that means giving Gas very cheap and cost.. and not see them closing the pipes to Europe.. which will be far worse for Russia economy
So Putin policy is one of Total and absolute practical approach to maximize the best possible
its economy.. and you can see that by Russia -Turkey pipeline.. and business with Israel.
and still selling Space Engines to NASA .
So traditionally Putin policy in Russia. Is very Economic Oriented and not based on feelings..
but on numbers. but without ignoring Russian people. Now Russia is facing a high probability of
a major world war. and it needs to try to boost economy at any price,at any cost ,including reducing social spending.. because of the Nation security threat. So they buy as much Gold they can and spending in military as much as they can..and maintain open their economy with the west as much as they can. Before any war start.
Sberbank is being pressure by the west through its shareholders minority to cut relations with Crimea.. So putin have 2 options , Force the bank to do its will and risk the shareholders to leave the bank and damage the bank and Russia economy? Or.. find a loophole with another bank and continue providing the service in Crimea without affecting without having a blowback
to the banks in Russia?
People complain that Russia keep selling Gas to Ukraine instead after they killing ethnic Russians.. that already was explained .the blow back for shutting down the Gas will be worse.
People complaine Sberbank continues operating in Ukraine.. but the blowback of seeing their assets confiscated and having to pay later in courts Ukraine could be worse.
people do not understand why Russia continue business with Ukraine ..after they killing
civilians.. and that Russian banks are financing the Kiev war.. and so and so.. and that is half truths. what they don't see is the consequences ,the blowback that could happen if Russia
shut down any kind of relation with Ukraine . That will be Russia will no longer be able to sell
energy to Europe through Ukraine and will lose like 30% in sales Gazprom.. this will affect directly Russia economy more than Ukraine and significantly pull the entire Russia economy
into a longer recession and create unrest in Russia? See?
Putin decisions are brutally ,and extremely practical .To the point that he could be seen
as a "puppet to the west". But what they do not understand is that Putin measure
the pros and cons of any action.. and he will always choose the action that could allow Russia
to maintain its economy in a better shape.. and this is because he fully understand , how closely
related is the economy of a nation/with the unity of people and with nation security. and the last thing Putin wants is to not only have to fight Ukraine in their borders openly causing more civilians casualties.. but also have to deal with civilian unrest and revolutions in all Russian cities demanding jobs and food.
Money is everything.. Money is all, without money a country cannot exist
And what kind of help Russia can give Crimea or Ukrainians if Putin assault their own
banking institutions and scare all investors..The Ruble value is very sensitive to politics
in Russia.. and any perception of Russia nationalizing its banks and closing the banks to western investors will sink the Ruble value ,more than what could Obama and saudi oil price wars could have done.
Many Russians citizens will support in a second that Crimean returns to Ukraine , if thats the only way for them to get their jobs back and food for their families. So this is why Russia needs to lift the siege on Russia economy by the west and NOT closing Russia doors to the western investments. even if that means annoying at times the comfort of their own people. and to try to minimize the effect of sanctions of the west. But a balanced approach is needed.
And this is done because Russia is still unfortunately dependent of trade with the west. for technology . As long as Russia does not offer a strong alternative to Intel/apple /Microsoft/European Automobile industry ,everyone wants a BMW ,and develop their own internet , their own fashion /and entertainment industry./their entertainment technology like LCD giant screens or home stereos etc... they will continue to buy everything from foreign companies. Because they will see most of the things they want are there .
The good news is that Russia do have the capabilities to replace anything that US and European
produce.. but they should have started a decade or two ago with the full Industrial revolution and not now.. anyway better late than never..
If someone tells me that Russia central bank is 100% private and Russian government have no
shares there,and now to influence them. that will be a complete different thing.. and that will be treason ..but perhaps someone can educate me here if im wrong. .but i don't think this is the case.
Last edited by Vann7 on Tue Jun 09, 2015 11:13 pm; edited 1 time in total