GarryB wrote:Bad propaganda is... you have a competent leader who is denying use cheap and easy money to be made asset stripping your country and screwing its people over like we have done with so many countries before.- u just described Putin who allows his oligarchs to rape the country!-why should but r not critical of all propaganda-it's a 2way street.
So you are saying I should give Nazis a fair go because maybe I just don't understand what their real message is. Maybe the KKK are just people who want to be loved and cuddled and are misunderstood too...-read Beyond Good & EvilBias is all over ur posts (with minimal critical thinking where it should be applied, not with personal attacks & syllogysms & exaggerations u r so good at), which must take all sides of a given issue into account.
So eventually he did what everyone else gets very little choice in doing and followed the law and being a criminal made things tough for him... well that is a surprise.... breaking the law, becoming a criminal, and then suffering for that... isn't that how the real world works?- FYI, in the 1990s there, no business could succeed by following the law from the Socialist USSR era.-he later paid taxes but Putin didn't like his back talk & ruined his life.
Putin 1st financial crime was in St Petersburg when he embezzled $ from exports; as the French say: u get hungrier as u eat. He applied laws against others that crossed him & his buddies but not to himself; as a de-facto Tsar, he is above the law.
The shock and horror is that this is not what happens in the west..- the Russians in Russia don't live in the West, & have to survive in their present situation. & could care less about Western abuses.
But Putin is the boss... he is in charge... he is murdering people in the UK with military grade nerve agents and interfering in elections around the world for the last 10 years at least... surely anyone who made any money in Russia would need to pay tribute to the boss... that is how such things work don't you know...-generalizing again! certain people who made certain amount$!- not every rich person, & it wasn't easy to trace & took a long time to uncover everything.
Putin knows he is no threat but he brings other idiots out of the woodwork, and I am sure they are recording names and faces and links to the west...-if it was so, he wouldn't be taping his denials on that Palace & finally getting Rotenberg to claim its ownership. If he was the real owner, why not come out sooner?.-they would've used other pretexts w/o Navalny, the West has many options, so don't blame it on him only.
What makes you think they are his. Even the most basic TV programme has a wardrobe section that dresses everyone in appropriate costumes.... do you think presidents have to dress themselves?- he isn't a poor actor like Zelensky was. In fact, he is a lot richer than Trump & Reagan put together. ur straw grasping is ridiculous & becoming annoying!.- just look at his wristwatches & suits, & he has a lot more in his collection that r worth more than all of his incomes put together.
..are you going to say the limo is his too? How about the aircraft he flys around in?- stop interrogating me, I already posted info. on his non-gov. vehicles that r registered under different owners, but under his control.
There was nothing close to 50% of the Russian population at any of those protests... closer to 1%, and it is not clear they were all pro Navalny... I have seen some people who were supporting Putin.-they were all anti-Putin, & those who hesitate will join them as the regime can only act with more oppression.- most Russians want him gone to, for their reasons that were building up for the last 20 years.
Every few years they have a vote for the last 30 odd years. They have more parties and candidates than the US does so more of a democracy than the US... which is not really saying much at all.- u omit the fact that many were prevented from registering, incl. Navalny who was put in legal trouble by the orders from above. Not bad for being democratic!-where is any evidence of Russian democracy?
Well if that is the only democracy that ever existed then can we stop wasting time talking about such shit.The only democracy of sorts that ever existed there was in Novgorod that was never occupied by the Mongols & which Moscow brutally crushed.
Western so called democracies have used their money and power and secret services to undermine more real democracies than those pretending to be democracies that make up the west.-pl. rant about them on other treads- this 1 is about Russian Lib. Opposition, in case u forgot.
Surely his fame is what makes him worth killing, because murdering him would be a statement to all of Putins enemies that no one is safe... or are you trying to say Putin is too scared to kill him now that his poisoned underpants scheme has failed... -then, some1 will kill Putin for sure. PM Stolypin was way better statesman but still got shot. Perhaps if he lived, Russia would be a stable constitutional monarchy now.-Navalny is too famous now; recall that even mighty Brezhnev's KGB couldn't do much to Solzhenitsyn & Sakharov.
Benefit in what way? With him dead the west wont stop doing what they are doing...-do u have ADD? I was talking about Nemtsov's death.- by the same token, Putin would benefit a lot more from his death & from blaming it on the West or anti-Kadyrov Chechens.
So medias job is to push an agenda and they are not responsible for telling anyone elses story... get your own new network.-they r not his media;
So why do you blame RT and Sputnik for being Putins mouthpieces... isn't that just him having his say... or as president of Russia he is not allowed a voice?-he got too much voice, so much that people had to take to the streets from the RFE to Kaliningrad in freezing temperatures.
What taxpayers money... they have been wrong about everything so far, why do you think they might be right about the funding?-the FSO is financed by the gov., i.e. the taxpayers of all kinds; many young people have 2-3 jobs to support their parents &/ grandparents receiving low pensions; all those age groups r among the protesters.-the Russians care, it's their $ that were wasted on it, + the tax $ used to guard that palace with FSO- if it's oligarchs to enjoy, then they should pay for it.
The west is hoping for that... expecting that...- if they do, they r morons- how will they handle several new states with nukes? they were lucky when Ukraine & Kazakhstan gave their nukes to Russia.-Russia won't collapse w/o Putin, get that idea out of ur head!
the west has forgotten what real suffering is, yet deals it out on a day to day basis... yes... the west does need to suffer.- it already does with Covid-19/20, refugees, climate change, riots, & moral decline.- so u wish the West to suffer?
Yeah, but being at the arse end of the world and not on the best terms with the US we do have a bit of leeway... you will notice we are rather more diplomatic in our conversations with China... it is simply about respect... something most of the west has forgotten sadly.- perhaps if it becomes a new Chinese colony/province, along with Australia, it'll be shielded better, but that time is too far off...isn't NZ a part of it?
He deserves a better palace than we could afford to build him.- I would love to see ur pic greeting him at the airport & kissing his boots!It could be a good site to build another big palace for Putin, & where he could enjoy using his yachts & local girls!
Have I upset you?-yes, with stupid ?s & insinuations like these.- r u a political strategist? if so, go earn some $ & donate it to Putin's United Russia Party instead of wasting time on a forum.
Well he knows the poisoning bullshit was all bullshit so there was no risk at all... he knew he broke the rules and he knew he was going to jail and the protests at his arrest were planned before he arrived.-a brave thing to do indeed;
I believe the word is traitor.- u r full of crap up to ur ears to believe all this trash.
He knows Putin knows he is not worth a bullet. People die in custody all the time... and get raped too...- then, why return & make his wife a widow& his 2 daughters orphans?he also knows that trying to killing him now will cost Putin a lot more than it did before.
Hopefully the penalties for his new crimes can be financial. It makes more sense to take money from this idiot and set him free than waste a prison cell for this moron and give him time to write a book or some such crap.-no, Putin is afraid that out of jail he'll lead the opposition. U can bet I know his thought process a lot better than u do.- no, he now lives in jail, on gov. $. If/when he gets out, he'll have enough $ w/o any from abroad.
Putin is just the head. When Putin leaves the FSB and police and courts and media and rich people will remain the same... they don't change... in Russia and in the US and everywhere else.- dead wrong: the elites & their law enforcers change with the regime they supported. Yeltsin & Putin r transitory figures, just like Andropov & Gorbachev were.Today, the Russians deserve some1 different & better than Putin, his FSB, riot police, courts, media & oligarchs have to offer.
Russia has had almost 30 years experience with that American written bullshit constitution... I am surprised and a little disappointed they didn't change it sooner and rather more radically.- FYI, his plan was to unite with Belarus & become a head of the new state, but Lukashenko wanted also to be that head & rotate with PM position, like Medvedev did. Changing the constitution was an emergency measure to keep Putin in power, not to improve the lives of Russians.-Putin & his advisers were so concerned, they changed the constitution not for his own benefit-that was last on his mind-but to allow his voters the opportunity to exercise democracy; how generous on their part!
That is the opposite of the ends justify the means...-were those Nazi generals plotting to kill Hitler to save Ms of lives not justified? a while ago I saw a man holding a sign saying "Putler- Kaput!"-2 wrongs doesn't make it right;
If putin is so bad he will be replaced next election.- even if it would happen, the people had had enough of him to wait till 2024.if Putin rule was so good, then his media and riot police better be more professional & stop defending a lost cause.
Navalny isn't their future... he doesn't even want to be.- their better future as they see it is w/o Putin, & Navalny wants to be their future president. stop mincing words!- it'll be Ms as time goes by & more people take a stand in their future.
Someone in the west who has taken an interest in Russia over these last few decades and seen what a miracle Putin has achieved in a relatively short space of time. -Lenin & Stalin also pulled impressive miracles, but cost Ms of lives; that's why it wasn't a miracle but a natural event that the USSR imploded, costing more lost lives. If Putin stays, the country will stagnate just like it did under Brezhnev, if not worse.Who r u to claim that Putin is the best for Russia till 2024 or 2036?
But they should listen to you?- no, they have others they know to listen to & I'm not their advisor. STOP PERSONAL ATTACKS!!!!!Those who live there could care less what GB or any1 else says on this English language forum.
You are claiming the Russian police are barbaric, and I am making the point that vastly more people got killed in the US and France than protesting in Russia...- 1 life lost is too many; the Putin regime must self-liquidate ASAP or there will be more strife & possibly a civil war, & that's the bottom line.- it's their fight, not French or American, & whom their ancestors defeated & kicked out in 1812 & 1918-19.
the west blaming everyone else for the things happening in the west...- & u r blaming the West for everything bad that happens in Russian power dynamics! look for a log in ur own eye before pointing a speck in mine!
Navalny in the Moscow City Court
“We cannot influence the lawlessness perpetrated by this judge”: what are the judges of Navalny known for?
Last edited by Tsavo Lion on Wed Feb 03, 2021 1:21 am; edited 5 times in total (Reason for editing : add link)