kvs wrote:Kimppis wrote:http://tass.com/economy/982340
So Russia's GDP is only up 1.4% from January to November? Well, I guess it makes sense if the economy really grew only by 1% in November. But that is quite a disappointment, so much for that 2%, which I thought was if anything conservative... ffs the economy was up by 2.5% in Q2, 3.1% in May.
So how the fuck was the growth much higher during H1!? It means IMF, and RCB were more accurate than the Ministry of Economic Development?
I know it's largely symbolic, I mean it's the first year of growth since 2014, but it seems to interest rates really are hurting... Or maybe I'm not reading that right. (Yeah, just read it again and I don't think so. There's no way around it, from January to November the growth was only 1.4%.) The slowdown is actually huge, damn...
It is a miracle that Russia has positive GDP growth at all given the insane CBR rate policy. This is not
a joke, the prime rate is one of the key controls over economic activity. In fact, it can be more important than
changes in government spending since most of the private sector does not directly depend on the government and
its spending.
It is clear that many people on this board do not have a clue about the importance of this issue. You all should
make an effort and note that all the major projects (e.g. Nord Stream II, high speed rail) all require massive
bank loans up-front. No commercial entity uses savings for investment. This is why NATO tries to sanction Russia
via access to banks. Nabiullina is a rank A criminal who knows that Russian companies are desperate for affordable
loan rates (under 4%). Perhaps Gazprom can arrange for global financing at reasonable rates, but not every
Russian company is a high roller that can get such deals. And when it comes to small and medium sized business,
they are totally f*cked.
That is true, the interest rates seem to be really high. But I don't think it's some sort of a huge conspiracy against Russian interests or something:
1. The current priority is not the short-term economic growth, it's inflation
2. The CBR argues that its policy is not based on the current level of inflation per se, but 1. on general population's inflation expectations, which are still really high, because inflation has been so high historically and 2. CBR expects the inflation drop to below 3% to be only temporary, and that it will go back up to 4% next year even with their hawkish policy (that seems to be one of their overly conservative and pessimistic predictions, tbh)
3. http://www.unz.com/akarlin/russias-inflation-falls-to-record-post-soviet-low/ (Everyone should read this. Seems logical, the article was already posted here a while ago.)
4. I do agree that CBR is too "conservative". it's too pessimistic about the sanctions, their effects and the current development level and resilience of the Russian economy in general.
Putin publicly announced that the government's objective should be to achieve an economic growth rate above the global average (so around 3% per year) by 2019 or 2020. The interest will be already considerably lower by the end of next year in any case, so we'll see what the effect is going to be. There are also a few things to consider:
1. If the economy will only really grow by around 1.5%, the criticism towards CBR is sure to increase considerably. Atleast that should certainly be the case. The Ministry of Economic Development publicly expected the economic growth to be above 2%, as did Medveded and Putin at times. I feel 2% is symbolically important, atleast it's for me lol. 2% sounds so much better than say, 1.5%. And btw, Hellevig was expecting growth rates close to 3%. Not to mention that the economy grew by 2.5% in Q2, so what the hell happened after that!? How was Q2 by far the best quarter of the year? Is that somehow normal for the Russian economy?
2. They made some adjustments to methodology last year, and the economic growth rates from 2015 and 2016 were increased considerably. The same thing might happen again, but we'll only find that out... maybe in six months time.