What the Central Bank achieves with unexpected decisions, by Olga Samofalova for VZGLYAD.
April 9, 2022.
The Bank of Russia has changed its key rate for the second time at an emergency meeting. This time, he cut the rate sharply from 20% to 17%. Previously, the Central Bank, with high inflation, did not even think of taking such hasty steps. However, the situation in the economy is now largely unique, and the regulator has begun to act within the framework of the new economic logic. Where it leads?
The Russian Central Bank cut its key rate by 300 basis points from 20% to 17%. The decision was unexpected for many. On the one hand, it was clear that a sharp increase in the rate to 20% was a forced and temporary decision. On the other hand, few people expected that the reverse trend would start so soon and so sharply – with a step of 300 bp at once. Many expected a more modest rate cut not earlier than April 29, when the scheduled meeting of the regulator will take place.
What prompted the Central Bank of the Russian Federation to cut the rate unscheduled on April 8? The next meeting of the regulator is scheduled for April 29. However, he did not wait for him. Moreover, experts do not exclude that on April 29 there will be another rate cut to 14-15%.
Previously, in making decisions, the Central Bank proceeded from the main goal - keeping inflation at the target level of 4%, and depending on the indicators of real inflation, it made a decision on the rate. Now the situation with inflation looks ambiguous. Annual inflation accelerated to 16.7%, on the other hand, weekly inflation slowed down by half compared to March peaks. Previously, the Central Bank would have waited for a much longer decline in price growth than one week. However, the new economic conditions, apparently, may dictate other goals for the regulator.
It is unlikely that the Bank of Russia's goal was to weaken the ruble, which has strengthened by almost eight rubles this week, even despite the introduction of new sanctions by the US (Wednesday) and the EU (Friday). As the VZGLYAD newspaper wrote , such a strong ruble harms not only Russian exporters, but also the revenue side of the Russian budget. The budget includes a ruble exchange rate of 72.1 per dollar, and if the dollar is cheaper, then this creates a deficit. Experts agree that the economic block of the government can consider 80 rubles to the dollar a comfortable ruble exchange rate.
However, the level of the Central Bank's rate has an extremely weak effect on the ruble exchange rate, especially now, when there is a whole series of restrictions on buying and selling foreign currency. In such conditions, the rate becomes unimportant for the exchange rate. “In the context of restrictions on the movement of capital, the relationship between the exchange rates of the ruble and the size of the key rate is decreasing. This is due to the fact that there are no non-residents in the foreign exchange market, and local investors experience problems with access to foreign capital markets. Thus, capital restrictions minimize the competitive valuation of the ruble and the profitability of ruble assets,” explains Vladimir Evstifeev, head of the analytical department of Zenit Bank. If the authorities want to weaken the ruble, then relaxations in terms of currency restrictions will be much more effective measures. Apparently, they will soon follow. Maybe.
As for the Central Bank, this time it decided to lower the rate largely based on the general state of the economy. The regulator worries about a sharp decline in economic growth, so he gave the first breath of air to the economy as soon as he saw the first signs of a slowdown in inflation and changes in the banking sector.
To all appearances, the Central Bank is not afraid to drive up inflation with its drastic actions. The reason for this lies in the fact that the nature of inflation is now also different than before. Prices are rising due to a shortage of goods, due to problems with logistics and sanctions, and even due to panicked demand from the population for some types of goods. This rate cannot be affected. Of course, the devaluation of the ruble to 120 per dollar in the first weeks after February 24 contributed to inflation. But now the exchange rate can be kept in the region of 75-80 per dollar with the help of currency restrictions.
“Increasing the key rate in February was one of the anti-crisis measures, the purpose of which was to stabilize the financial system. This goal has already been achieved: the outflow of liquidity from banks has been stopped, and there is an inflow into deposits. There is no longer a need for such a high value of the key rate,” says Evstifeev. Another thing is that geopolitical risks for the deterioration of the situation in the financial system still remain. Therefore, the size of the key rate is not declining as fast as it was raised, Evstifeev notes.
“The situation in the banking sector has changed. At the peak of the financial crisis in early March, the structural liquidity deficit reached 7 trillion rubles, and now it has been replaced by a structural surplus of 1.5 trillion rubles,” says Olga Belenkaya, Head of the Macroeconomic Analysis Department at FG Finam.
This means that the high rate did its job: deposits became attractive, and people took money to banks, providing them with liquidity. At the same time, interest rates on loans rose so much that they actually killed lending, with the exception of preferential programs from the state. And loans are the engine of the economy. In a few months, they will go down following the reduction of the key rate by 1-3%. This, of course, is not much. Therefore, the Central Bank hints that it will continue to lower the rate further. Unless, of course, the remaining geopolitical risks do not work: new tough sanctions are not introduced, namely, the oil and gas embargo. So far, no one is betting on such an outcome.
“I think this is not the last key rate cut. As it decreases, rates on deposits and loans will decrease. Other things being equal, lowering the rate has a stimulating effect on the economy through the expansion of lending,” says Vladimir Bragin, Director for Financial Markets and Macroeconomics at Alfa Capital. The rate cut is possible up to 15%, which will become a catalyst for support measures, reforms and transformations initiated by the relevant ministries, Evstifeev believes.
Forecasts about the fall of Russian GDP this year reach up to 15%. However, at Zenit Bank, the baseline forecast so far assumes a 7.3% fall in Russia's GDP in 2022, but it may be changed depending on the measures taken to support the economy.
It is also difficult to make forecasts because there are no macroeconomic statistics for March and the first quarter of the year, which could be guided by. “So far, only inflation data has been released, as well as the results of a survey of companies and the population regarding the assessment of the situation and expectations for the future. And, judging by these data, something catastrophic did not happen to business activity. So there is a chance that there will be no deep drawdown at the end of the year,” says Bragin.
According to Finam analysts, in the coming months there will be a noticeable reduction in economic activity, combined with high inflation, which by the end of the year may reach the level of 20-25%. “We tentatively expect a 6-8% decline in GDP by the end of the year, much will depend on the duration of Western sanctions, the ability of businesses to replace retiring imports, the effectiveness of support measures from the state and the Central Bank,” experts believe.
The most vulnerable industries in Russia may be aviation, the automotive industry, IT, and the financial sector. Among the more protected are the oil and gas sector, the production of fertilizers, and non-ferrous metallurgy. “Our sympathies are now on the side of commodity export companies, the least affected by the sanctions. Oil and gas risks are lower compared to other sectors, and local supply failures are offset by high commodity prices. In the context of the food crisis, agricultural chemicals will also be in demand, which will protect fertilizer producers from restrictions,” Finam notes.
https://vz.ru/economy/2022/4/9/1152855.html