Russian special military operation in Ukraine #52

Completely agree, Russian MOD need to hire new people or let interns run the show

Why? They told us that they destroyed Himars multiple times.
Reaction from those who know better?
Can´t be!
Pictures are not good enough.
Was something else...

Exactly. Business as usual.

If India sold the stuff directly and not so some other nation who "gifted" it to Banderaland.
Remember the tanks from Marocco?

Even if someone else paid India for it and they shipped it to Ukraine it still doesn't matter a rats ass.

Hole wrote:
Why? They told us that they destroyed Himars multiple times.
Reaction from those who know better?
Can´t be!
Pictures are not good enough.
Was something else...

You are missing the point. It’s about not doing their job right. If they did, it would eliminate this telegram group nonsense where one group wants to flex on another. Pictures I attached were from group, not MOD!

Unified and proper PR and media reach through Zvezda TV is what many want, this bullshit what we get is silly. No crappy music, no childish jokes or convoluted nonsense, just official channels. Don’t you agree? I am tired of following 150+ channels that eventually want to sell me a winter hat/knife/backpack as owner wants to make money

January . Special military operation progress, stay tuned for tomorrow:

Russia is launching sensitive strikes on Ukrainian military facilities today and will do so tomorrow after the terrorist attack in Belgorod, Putin said. He noted that Russia would intensify strikes on Kiev's military facilities.

The number of victims of the shelling of Belgorod on 30 December has risen to 25 people, including 5 children, Governor Gladkov said. He said a 4-year-old girl died in hospital today in a serious condition.

Ukrainian troops fired 15 MLRS rockets at Donetsk 10 minutes into the New Year. The head of the DPR reported 4 dead and 13 wounded.

In Odessa, explosions damaged port infrastructure, the Ukrainian military said.

Ukrainian media reported explosions in Kiev amid an air alert; local authorities noted that air defence systems were operating in the suburbs.

On 31 December, the Russian armed forces launched a strike with long-range airborne precision weapons against the infrastructure of airfields where Storm Shadow cruise missile carriers were based, hitting all facilities, the defence ministry said.

Russian troops hit a drone production facility near the town of Chuguev in the Kharkov region, four fuel depots for AFU military equipment near Odessa, Dnepropetrovsk and the town of Konstantinovka in the Nikolaev region, the Defence Ministry said.

Two Ukrainian drones were neutralised in the Bryansk region during the day, with no casualties or damage, the governor said.

Putin presented the participants in the special operation with commemorative badges - copies of the presidential standard - at the Novo-Ogarevo residence near Moscow. The president said he had designed them himself.

@ukraine_watch

Regular wrote:

Incorrect about shortages. Listen what Sternenko and Madyar say. They are bottlenecked now and will feel draught soon. Chinese exports cannot be easily accessed to them, unlike Ru Gov contracts and private purchases.

not sure which war you are watching, they fly daily in Avdeevka


They block ranges of frequencies, not one channel. By the time they change anything, they will be out of action or loosing drones. There are more to this of course, but jammers can switch channels quicker than drones that can fall down the sky if telemetry is interrupted for a mere second. Frequency analysers are game changers here. You see what channels ukrs use kilometres away.

Ukros switch bands, they go from UHF to VHF, then back up again, jammers are programmed in bands, everytime they switch, jammers have to be reprogrammed

You are completely wrong with this. By 5-6 months.

which war are you watching? Russian forces are hiding in dugouts in Avdeevka because going outside means instant death

The drone situation has not been addressed, that's why they remain in the same positions for 2 months

This issue is the one thing holding Russia back from making more advances

Improvement in EW, and implementing squad SOP for EW is the main effort right now

1 jammer backpack per squad, and none of the squad members can leave more than 50m from the jammer, until it is assured that FPV operators have been eliminated or are suppressed

can they just strike the drone operators with their drones and artillery? They have a shortage of this or lack range?

thegopnik wrote:can they just strike the drone operators with their drones and artillery? They have a shortage of this or lack range?

The problem in Avdeevka is not just the city, but also the villages surrounding

Look at Stepove

Russia has overwhelming artillery and drone superiority , but Ukraine compensates asymmetrically

Numerous videos surfaced of Russian special forces throwing grenades in trenches and dugouts, where Ukrainians are inside some kind of fortifications

That is the situation, Ukraine is not attacking anymore, they have disappeared from view and are totally entrenched

Meanwhile, Russian troops have to expose themselves when attempting to advance

So you have overwhelming artillery and drone support, but no targets to identify or hit

Meanwhile Ukrainians with a steady supply of FPV, are capable of knocking a platoon out of combat, or knocking out resupply convoys and disabling their armored escorts

It has nothing to do with quantity of weapons when Ukrainians are dug in

They nullify the advantage in munitions superiority, but they become more of a guerilla force than an actual functioning military

And that is what we see - The Ukrainian military is no longer combat effective in the open

For now Russian troops are more or less digging in themselves in the positions they captured

All resupply is done by drone, and robotized "bukhanka"

This is what has brought casualties lower, but there is no movement, as the surface is like a no man's land

PapaDragon wrote:As long as they aren't donating them to Ukraine or blocking Russia from buying them should they ask it's a valid play

India is not exporting any weapons to Ukraine.

These are artillery shells that US purchased from India as part of the offset deal and susequently exported to Ukraine.

https://www.defensenews.com/land/2023/10/06/us-army-awards-15b-to-boost-global-production-of-artillery-rounds/

GarryB wrote:If this is true however it makes Indian complaints at Russian sales of weapons to Pakistan look rather amusing.

Russia sells billions of $ of weapons to China that China fields against India. Russia also sells state of the art small arms to Pakistan that are routinely used against India.

So using these events as precedents India can export weapons to Ukraine. But India doesn't. These are artillery shells that India had exported to the US who are in turn exporting them to Ukraine.

Concentrating on figuring out the signals of where the drones are coming from amd striking said areas is key. I don't think jamming will be that effective but I could be wrong. They may be able to create heavy EM weapon but it would also possibly render Russian drones useless as well in the area used. But not a bad idea if needing to advance by having some kind of heavy EM weapons running within a certain range creating an umbrella for Russian troops.

But new ELINT equipment, maybe even a drone, would be ideal in sniffing out drone operators in the battlefield.

Sujoy wrote:

GarryB wrote:If this is true however it makes Indian complaints at Russian sales of weapons to Pakistan look rather amusing.

Russia sells billions of $ of weapons to China that China fields against India. Russia also sells state of the art small arms to Pakistan that are routinely used against India.

So using these events as precedents India can export weapons to Ukraine. But India doesn't. These are artillery shells that India had exported to the US who are in turn exporting them to Ukraine.

Like just about every arms deal done, there will be clause where you can't sell on of gift to another country without the say so if the original supplier. It's common practice, USA is the worst for it. So if India finds out that USA has done this against the sales agreement then India could take legal action or refused any further military deals based on this. And if India has got any balls it should do. Russia is far more of ally to India than USA will ever be.

Young blood in leadership ? The old think differently . War is a young man's business . Peace an old man's hobby . India selling ? Well Turkey was selling drones too ! Everybody making money . But some you can shepherd into the pen . Others are beyond reach . Advancing in the open ? No need . Build trench digging machines and advance troops behind them . They have much bigger tunnel digging machines underground ! WW1 style . Depth 50 cm , troops flat on Rollers !  " Heavy ! " attacks against Kiev ? You should look at old photo of Berlin at the end of WW2 . Artillery doing most of the damage . Buffer zone against them practical , not against Rockets launched from 300 km away . During any partition plan , citizens will be offered a choice . If they stay , then they follow the rules .

d_taddei2 wrote:Like just about every arms deal done, there will be  clause where you can't sell on of gift to another country without the say so if the original supplier. It's common practice, USA is the worst for it. So if India finds out that USA has done this against the sales agreement then India could take legal action or refused any further military deals based on this.

Not that easy. The US will simply remove that made in India logo on the shells so that they appear to have been manufactured in the US.

Isn't there a Western arms embargo on China? Then how come Germany is selling engines for tanks, submarines to China? France is selling cruise missiles to China that China simply rebrands and exports.

GarryB wrote:If it turns out to be remotely true then Russia should simply ask India to produce some 152mm and 122mm artillery shells for them to return the favour.

How will these street shitters manufacture 152mm shells when they don't even have the capability? 152mm is a Russian round.

These low lifes will have to set up an entire manufacturing facility with the proper tooling, engineers that know the specifications to make the new production ammunition safe and compatible with the existing guns, and train workers to do it. This isn't a quick or easy thing to do--you're talking about several years of work before the first round comes off the production line. All this assuming they even have skilled engineers. Their engineers are almost always mediocre.

good night guys

[quote="Arkanghelsk"]

not sure which war you are watching, they fly daily in Avdeevka

I am watching same SMO, some of your claims are very weird and make no sense.
Like this one. Ukrainians use artillery daily as well, does it mean they have shell shortage or not? They die in droves in Krinky, does that mean they have people shortage or not? Build a narraritive on trends and this will set you free.

Small tidbit
Recorded Russian FPV strikes & common Ukrainian complaint





Ukros switch bands, they go from UHF to VHF, then back up again, jammers are programmed in bands, everytime they switch, jammers have to be reprogrammed
Frequency hopping is very limited and would still cause FPV drone to eat dirt, mere second of telemetry/control loss can be fatal for the drone.
Also, regards frequency hopping and jamming and programming… Look closer into this screeshot


which war are you watching? Russian forces are hiding in dugouts in Avdeevka because going outside means instant death

Hiding in dugouts, yet squeeze on Avdeevka is getting stronger. Many dugouts near Berdichi? What is going on there?

The drone situation has not been addressed, that's why they remain in the same positions for 2 months
Two months, nothing changed around Avdiivka? What can I say, I am not the smartest person, but can Jamie pull out the map from Creamy Caprice and compare it? I am against spoon feeding, especially when your statement is contrarian one

This issue is the one thing holding Russia back from making more advances
FPV drones?… mines, fortifications, atgms, artillery, tanks, ifvs, infantry

Improvement in EW, and implementing squad SOP for EW is the main effort right now

1 jammer backpack per squad, and none of the squad members can leave more than 50m from the jammer, until it is assured that FPV operators have been eliminated or are suppressed

And source of this is what? I am really worried I missed something, especially main effort bit and 50 meters… What about Bulat project? Don’t see you mentioning it, yet all drone groups are talking about it and not about backpacks. Sorry man, you are very pessimistic and hold weird narrative

Sujoy wrote:

d_taddei2 wrote:Like just about every arms deal done, there will be  clause where you can't sell on of gift to another country without the say so if the original supplier. It's common practice, USA is the worst for it. So if India finds out that USA has done this against the sales agreement then India could take legal action or refused any further military deals based on this.

Not that easy. The US will simply remove that made in India logo on the shells so that they appear to have been manufactured in the US.

Isn't there a Western arms embargo on China? Then how come Germany is selling engines for tanks, submarines to China? France is selling cruise missiles to China that China simply rebrands and exports.

In many past wars we have seen marked equipment and ammo and nobody bothered to go to the effort, time and money, to scrub off and reprint ammo. And Indian shells apparently already shown up in images in Ukraine. If India wants to make a buck then they should sell to Russia it's ally, or if USA asks them to sell to them India should simply offer them at 5 times the price if USA really wants them then let them buy above the cost if not tell them to go jump.