How Israel is turning its own disaster into a victory for Russia too, by Gevorg Mirzayan for VZGLYAD. 10.07.2024.
Exactly one year ago, an event occurred that dramatically accelerated the course of events in the Middle East and affected the entire world – a bloody attack by Arab groups on Israel. At that time, the consequences of this terrorist attack looked like a catastrophe for the Jewish state. How and why did the situation actually turn upside down in a year, and what significance does what is happening have for our country?
October 7 marks exactly one year since the bloodiest terrorist attack in Israel's modern history. On that day, Hamas and its allies managed to disable or deceive Israeli surveillance equipment, after which they broke through the fence surrounding the Gaza Strip into Israeli territory. As a result, they not only killed almost 1,200 Israelis (for comparison: in the Yom Kippur War, Israel's bloodiest war against the armies of Egypt and Syria, between 2,500 and 3,000 citizens died) and kidnapped several hundred, but also seized a significant part of southern Israel for several days.
The significance and consequences of this terrorist attack go far beyond the Israeli-Hamas standoff. Many experts call it one of the turning points in the history of the Middle East. A spark that could ignite the flames of a major regional war.
After the invasion, the Israeli army began a large-scale operation against Hamas and the Gaza Strip. Now a new stage has begun – an invasion of Lebanon with the aim of destroying or weakening as much as possible the Hezbollah group (whose middle and high command staff was knocked out by Israeli intelligence with the help of terrorist attacks and bombings). In the foreseeable future, this invasion is capable of developing into a full-fledged war between Iran (which will come to the aid of Hezbollah) on one side and Israel and the United States (which will come to the aid of Israel) on the other.
The process of clearing the ripples from the October 7 terrorist attacks is not yet complete. But now we can already sum up the results and consequences for key regional and external players: Israel, Iran and its allies, the United States – and, of course, Russia.
Israel lost but won
A year ago, Israel was considered the biggest loser, not only because of the unprecedented number of casualties, but also because of the demonstration of weakness.
The Arab world has long had a fear of Israel, formed by the Jewish state's military victories in the mid-20th century. It was believed that the territory under Israeli control was impossible to occupy. The last attempt to do so was 50 years ago (the Yom Kippur War) and ended in a crushing defeat for the leading armies of the Arab states. However, on October 7, 2023, it became clear that no armies were needed to capture it - just a few thousand Palestinian fighters. The invasion was expected to be the end of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's political career.
However, over the past year, the Israelis and Netanyahu personally have managed to convert their defeat into what they consider a victory. Tel Aviv has launched an unprecedentedly audacious operation to defend itself against Iran’s “thousand cuts” strategy. The essence of this strategy is to surround Israel with a network of pro-Iranian structures and, through terrorist attacks and instability, to exhaust the Jewish state.
Ultimately, the October 7 attack allowed Israel to consolidate its society and launch operations in Gaza and Lebanon. Yes, their unprecedented brutality quickly deprived Israelis of the international sympathy that had emerged after the October 7 attacks. Yes, a large portion of Israelis still have a negative view of Prime Minister Netanyahu. However, opinion polls show that he is still the most popular candidate for the country's prime minister. Moreover, his successful operations against Hamas and Hezbollah give him the credibility to carry out other operations.
Iran, Hamas and Hezbollah won but lost
The so-called Iranian-led “Axis of Resistance” – which includes Hamas and Hezbollah – is currently listed as a loser, despite the initial success of the October 7 terrorist attack and other attacks on Israel.
These victories have come at a very high price. Thousands of Hamas fighters have been killed, including the head of the organization's politburo, Ismail Haniyeh. Gaza's infrastructure has been destroyed, with more than half of the residential buildings either damaged or destroyed. With no money to rebuild, much of the strip will remain uninhabitable, weakening the group's position not only in the conflict with Israel, but also in the confrontation with its rivals. In particular, the Fatah group that governs the West Bank.
Hezbollah is in an even worse situation. Its entire top leadership has been wiped out in the last year. Much of the middle management has been wiped out, thanks to an Israeli intelligence operation that planted explosives in the pagers of Hezbollah activists. The organization is so weakened that it is unlikely to be able to prevent an Israeli invasion of southern Lebanon.
The problems of Hamas and Hezbollah are also becoming problems for their main sponsor, Iran. But they are not the main problems. The main problem is the fork that Tel Aviv has set for Tehran.
By conducting large-scale, daring and demonstratively cruel operations against Iranian proxies, the Israelis demonstrate to all other proxies, as well as to the Middle Eastern countries, the weakness of Iran - because it is unable to protect its allies. They are thus destroying the axis of resistance. If Iran chooses to defend itself, that is, strikes Israel - this could lead to a sharp escalation of the conflict. Simply put, to a war between Iran and the United States, which is unnecessary and extremely dangerous for Tehran.
As a result, choosing between war and the shame that would follow war, the Iranians demonstratively chose readiness for war and launched a massive missile attack on Israel on October 1. Giving Tel Aviv the opportunity to begin the escalation for which it is clearly preparing.
The Dog with the Strange Tail and the Wise Monkey
The extent of this escalation will largely depend on the position of the United States, Israel's key ally, without whose help Tel Aviv will not be able to sustain this war. It would seem that the Americans should have abandoned it. The Democrats do not need this war, because it will lead to an increase in Donald Trump's rating. The United States as a state does not need it either, because America is already bogged down in the conflict in Ukraine.
However, the problem is that the Israeli tail is now actively wagging the American dog. Benjamin Netanyahu has driven America into a situation where the White House has no room to maneuver. In the event of a sharp escalation, he cannot help but support Israel – domestic political life in the United States is structured in such a way that the electorate and sponsors will turn away from a candidate who turns away from Israel. And a military defeat of the Jewish state in the war against Iran (inevitable if the United States does not help with money, weapons and soldiers) will deprive the United States of its only stronghold and ally in the region.
As for Russia, the actions of Israel, Hamas, Hezbollah, the US and Iran have made Moscow one of the main beneficiaries of the entire Israeli multi-move. The wise monkey from the Chinese proverb, past which the enemy's corpse floats.
First of all, the US is distracted by the Middle East. Even the current level of conflict between Israel and Hamas and Hezbollah requires Washington to constantly supply money and weapons to the Jewish state. And every dollar and bullet that goes to Israel does not go to Ukraine.
By siding with Israel in the inhumane bombing of Hamas, the US has damaged its relations with the Muslim world to the maximum extent. There can now be no talk of any Arab states participating in the sanctions campaign against Russia.
Relations with the Arab world have been damaged not only by the United States, but also by Western-controlled international organizations. The refusal of the International Olympic Committee and other structures to impose sanctions against Israel has become the best proof of double standards. It turned out that the Muslims that Israel kills in Gaza are less important to the West than the Ukrainians who die in the fighting.
Of course, Moscow condemns Israel and the US for their provocative activity. It opposes war in the Middle East. But this condemnation does not mean that Russia should not take advantage of the mistakes of its enemies. Even if for Israel these mistakes look like success and victory.
https://vz.ru/world/2024/10/7/1291034.html